Living into God’s Dreams for Restorative Justice: A New Season for Broad Street Ministry

by Rev. Greg Klimovitz

What do God’s dreams for redemption and restorative justice look like along the Avenue of the Arts in Center City, Philadelphia? For Broad Street Ministry (BSM), a worshipping community and faith-based not-for-profit nested in the old Chambers Wylie Memorial Presbyterian Church, these visions hinge on bridging the divide between the rich and the poor and neighbors marked as first and last by social norms. “We have dreams of making this a more just community,” affirmed Mike Dahl, Executive Director since 2016, “How can we build where everyone is well fed in all aspects of their lives? We dream of that future and know it can exist.”  When you walk through the large red doors of Broad Street Ministry and encounter the people there, you cannot help but believe the same.

While Broad Street Ministry has existed since 2005, the last few years have marked a new season of leadership. In addition to Mike Dahl’s arrival, the Rev. Laura Colee joined in 2018 as lead pastor of their worshipping community. Dahl and Colee both affirm the vital services they provide and radical hospitality they offer are intentional extensions of their identity as a Matthew 25 worshipping community. “There is something about us doing communion every week,” noted Rev. Colee. “[In our congregation] there are a lot of teachers, social workers, and lawyers. By doing communion every week, we are giving people that nourishment, the strength to get up every morning and keep doing this [justice] work. I love the way the worshipping community is able to fuel this important work, not only in this space, but throughout the city and surrounding area.”

As the bread and cup have fueled Broad Street Ministry, they have continued to experiment with fresh offerings of love and generosity alongside those more familiar with neglect and scarcity. In 2019, they gathered and scattered from the sacred table to extend over 71,000 free, five-star meals to guests who experience food insecurity. Additionally, Broad Street has partnered with the Philadelphia Orchestra to provide free musical jam sessions to their guests, distributed clothing to those in need of new threads for job interviews or to stay warm during the cold months, and offered mail and identification services to over 3,200 individuals in need of either an address or documentation so they can apply for a job, receive benefits, or register to vote. BSM also hosts a city-approved overnight cafe to Philadelphians experiencing homelessness. Located a block away from the “Gayborhood,” a section of the city known for LGBTQIA+ friendly residences, businesses, and entertainment, many who find sanctuary in the cafe identify as queer or transgender and may not be safe in other local shelter systems. All of this, in addition to the numerous partnerships with local businesses and churches that help to make it happen, is an extension of their identity as an open, affirming, and hopeful worshipping community. “[We hold] a fundamentally optimistic view. There is a belief in redemption,” said Mike Dahl. “With all the odds that are stacked against us and all the systems that are broken and everything that seems to be going wrong, there is one thing that you have to rely on to keep that going and that is faith.”

In 2017, this collective faith also spurred the launch of a new initiative and the hiring of a specialist to facilitate vital services for those who were either re-entering society after a period of incarceration or recently charged with a crime and in need of just consul. A grant recipient of our Presbytery’s 300th Anniversary Mission Campaign, this effort has allowed those who call Broad Street Ministry home to find access to all of the services noted above along with connections to legal assistance, leadership development, and vocational training through the endless networks and people associated with BSM. The dollars received enabled this program to move from an initial pilot to a stable and growing service. “We have always been a place where people would come when they get out [of prison] because they needed clothing or they needed a meal or they didn’t have anywhere else as an address,” noted Mike Dahl. “The question was, ‘what contribution were we going to make?’”

Since 2018, Broad Street has reported that their contributions have assisted their guests as they have avoided roughly 335 months of potential prison time, or the equivalent of 28 years of incarceration, through the reduction of recidivism, awareness of personal rights, access to legal consul, and more. In this way they have worked towards restorative justice and the dismantling of the prison pipeline, both key emphases of our Presbytery’s 300th Anniversary year of celebration and public witness. Rev. Colee added, “We have also largely been in conversation with the city itself about how we care for the residents and our neighbors, especially the folks who sometimes people want to sweep under the rug and say, ‘they are not our neighbors.’”

We continually give thanks for the work and witness of Broad Street Ministry. Their outreach alongside their neighbors on the Avenue of the Arts continues to draw us closer to God’s dreams for a more just and whole world. “I don’t think all churches have to look like us,” said Rev. Colee. “I think we are fulfilling a unique kind of space…We are just part of the that larger body and fulfilling a very particular need. I am grateful for that.” We, as a network of churches scattered throughout Greater Philadelphia, are grateful, too.

Listen to the PresbySpeak Podcast episode on iTunes here or SoundCloud below.